GitHub拒绝移除 cracked 软件副本,开发者需求保护
问题概述
GitHub在收到DMCA takedown后拒绝移除被盗版的Photopea副本,导致开发者声誉受损,且缺乏有效的执法途径。
痛点标签
- GitHub拒绝确认17 U.S. Code § 1201违规,导致DMCA takedown被驳回。
- 大量 cracked Photopea 仓库在GitHub上泛滥,官方渠道被稀释。
- 用户因使用被盗版版本而向开发者投诉,损害声誉。
- 处理 takedown 耗时且可能需要聘请律师,前景不确定。
待验证问题
- 你是否愿意提供被盗版仓库的具体链接以便进一步核实?
- 你是否已经尝试过其他平台的DMCA投诉,结果如何?
- 你是否考虑过在 Photopea 中实现域绑定或运行检测的技术方案?
证据
原话
I am a developer of https://www.photopea.com, a popular photo editor that runs in a web browser. Many people are asking AI models to take the Javascript code from my website, remove all ads from it, and they publish such a "new product" on Github for everyone to download. There exist tens of such repositories on Github.
原话 · @Anonymous
First off, let me get this out of the way - I am not a lawyer. If you want a legal advice talk to a lawyer. Second, I am sorry this is happening to you. Third, based on GitHub's reply, specifically> we're unable to confirm a violation of 17 U.S. Code § 1201 they took your submission as 17 U.S. Code § 1201 takedown notice.
原话 · @Anonymous
IP lawyer here - I can't give you actual legal advice because you aren't my client, but generally, you have two options here, neither of which will be surprising, or very satisfying: 1. Pay a lawyer or firm that specializes in this sort of thing to play whack a mole for you 2. Accept it as normal losses and ignore it.
原话 · @Anonymous
I suggest building in some heuristics that detect when Photopea is running outside of your domain. They don't need to be "foolproof," but add additional friction to pirating Photopea so that less people will jump through the hoops.
原话 · @Anonymous
Honestly, I was a hoping that giving attention to this problem here at HN might lead to someone from Github actually noticing my problem and looking into it.
免责声明:本卡片由 AI 从社区讨论中提炼,属于「痛点证据」,是需求分析与验证的起点,不等同于「已验证的市场需求」。AI 存在分析局限,关键决策前请打开上方原始讨论人工复核。